The Commissioner found that the HSE was not justified in its decision to refuse access to all of the records. She found that those parts of the records which did not disclose the personal information of persons other than the deceased fell to be released in accordance with Article 4(1)(b)(i) of the FOI Act, 1997 (Section 28(6)) Regulations, 2009. She found that those parts of the records which disclosed the personal information of persons other than the deceased were exempt under section 28(1). Accordingly, she varied the decision of the HSE and directed that parts of the records be released.